Home ..... Submit an article
Showing posts with label CSCI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CSCI. Show all posts

Friday, October 10, 2008

The death of light touch regulation?

The current global financial crisis unavoidably raises questions about the general rush towards "Light touch" regulation that has been a feature not only in financial regulation in the UK but also in the general UK approach to regulation.

The move towards light touch regulation may not have started in the Blair years but Tony Blair made clear during his premiership that his concern was to ensure that regulation did not get in the way of business. Indeed regulation was seen almost as an obstacle to the efficient functioning of business.

This agenda was, of course, driven in part by the self interests of the business lobby, many of whom saw regulation not as the legitimate exercise of control by society on their conduct but as an impediment in their pursuit of "efficiency".

We have now seen the consequences when regulation becomes so light touch that it fails to adequately grapple with the risks arising in a regulated sector. The consequences for us all following the clear failure of financial regulation will be serious and long lasting.

This pressure for light touch regulation has been all too apparent in the care sector with care provider representatives often pressing for a significant reduction in regulation and painting it solely as a burden.

In the care sector a significant failure of regulation might not have national economic consequences but it may have profound consequences for the lives of people who are being supported by care services. In the worst case scenario people may die because of inadeqaute checks of safety critical systems. They may suffer abuse through inadequate management control, training or recruitment of staff. They may suffer long term blight on their lives through the drip drip corrosive effect of care which is sub-standard.

While we should no more accept inadequate regulation of care services than we should of financial markets this is not a call for highly bearaucratic regulation. That is the opposite extreme and would be as equally destructive of good quality care as a lack of regulation.

What is need is risk based and proportionate regualtion. This is not the same as light touch regulation. Light touch regulation implies that the regulation system aims to touch lightly on all providers alike. This may not always be what is desired but this is too often where talk of light touch regulation takes us.

In contrast to this, a risk based and proportionate regulation system will be focussed on assessing the risks in the regulated sector and distinguishing and intervening in those areas where the risk is highest. It means reducing the regulatory "footprint" on services which are demonstrably of good quality - but increasing it in where risk oor poor performance is apparent.

A move away from "cyclical" inspection has been apparent recently, for example as recommended by the crerar review in Scotland. There is little doubt that standard cyclical inspection can often safely be reduced but great care must be taken in moving in this direction.

If regulation is to be calculated on the basis of risk and be proportionate this can only be on the basis of intelligence. It is vital that some of this intelligence is collected first hand so that the regulator does not have to rely excusively for extended periods on information provided by those who are regulated. This has serious implications for the extent to which frequency of inspection can be reduced in the care sector and regulators must ensure that frequency does not reduce to the extent that they may no longer have reliable information on which to make risk assessments.

Friday, February 01, 2008

Bristol Care Home Abuse Closure

Care regulator,The Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI) has applied for an emergency court order and closed Overnhill House, Downend, near Bristol. The care home for elderly people was shut because of concerns about the safety of residents following a period of monitoring.

Questions remain however about why there has so far been no police involvement given the nature of the concerns raised about what went on at the Overnhill home.

CSCI reported there had been complaints that one resident had been dragged across a room, that another had heavy bruising, concerns about issues about medication being administered and concerns about staffing levels .

All 10 people living at the Care Home were moved. The Owners, Danny Purgaus and Patricia Purgaus have not made any comment.

The home which has 14 beds was registered in 1992 and offered residential care for elderly people with dementia or Alzheimer's disease.

A CSCI spokesperson said, "The decision to close a care home is never taken lightly and is usually the last resort after every effort has been made to get the owners to improve standards and comply with legal requirements. We know all too well the impact that closure can have on the people who live there, their families and their carers, as well as members of the staff."

Bristol City Council said the authority had responded to concerns about the welfare of the residents and had found new residential placements for them.

An Avon and Somerset Police spokesperson confirmed that there has so far been no police involvement in the case.

The lack of police involvementy raises serious issues given the reports from CSCI that the complaints inluded the suggestion of at least one resident being dragged across the floor and the suggestion of heavy bruising on another.

Care Home residents are entitled not only to the protection afforded to them by a regulator such as CSCI - which appears to have acted firmly in this case. Care Home residents are also entitled to the protection afforded by the criminal law and it is clear that the police must investigate the possible abuse that may have taken place in this home.

Abuse of residents in care homes must be seen not only as a regulatory matter but also as a matter for possible criminal prosecution. Only when the State acts both to close such homes and to prosecute abusers will people in Care Homes feel truly protected.

Monday, April 02, 2007

CSCI hands over childrens services regulation

The Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI) has predicted that the handover of the inspection of children's services to education regulator Ofsted would not see immediate changes to the inspection approach.

CSCI's made the handover to Ofsted officially on April 1 at which point responsibility for regulation and inspection of most children's social care services in England moved from the Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI) to Ofsted.

The office of the children's rights director, Roger Morgan, based within CSCI, also joins the new Ofsted.

A CSCI statemnt said: "The inspection and regulation of children's services does not change significantly in the short term, with many CSCI staff transferring to Ofsted and continuing the focus on the experience of children who use services."

CSCI retains all functions for adult social care including services for younger adults and older people. It will also continue to regulate a small number of services that serve both adults and children - some home care services, nurses agencies, care homes and specialist further education colleges registered as care homes. CSCI will also continue to have an interest in the transition from children's to adults' services.

Ofsted also has a new title as the Office for Standards in Education, Children's Services and Skills.

Christine Gilbert, chief inspector of education, children's services and skills, , said: "The reach of the new inspectorate is extensive. At least one person in three makes use of the services we shall inspect or regulate. This puts us in a position to make a difference to the lives of many millions of our fellow-citizens, of all ages. This is a privilege, and a great responsibility."

Thursday, March 29, 2007

CSCI: One person childrens Homes and childrens services reports

A recent Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI) report raises questions about the value of "one-person children's homes". Councils can pay anything up to £6,000 a week to place children with extreme and complex needs in such homes but there appears to be no proof that approach benefits the children concerned.
In "one person children's homes" a child is often kept in a private house together with non-resident staff working in shifts. CSCI found that despite government guidance stressing the importance of children in care staying in their local area they are often located far from the child's own community.
The number of such children's homes is increasing, but it is not clear that councils have properly considered their efficacy. Children may stay in these homes for a few months or for periods of years.
CSCI notes that the homes are "extremely expensive" and questions whether the councils who are getting a good deal. Private providers are able to charge so much for the services because the provision is so scarce.

Denise Platt, CSCI chairwoman, said: "We don't know enough about how children respond to living on their own in these one place children's homes... It may well be convenient for local councils to place children with complex needs in these homes, but the impact on the children who live there is still unclear."
In some cases the impression was that the care process had not been "thought through", Dame Denise said.

Children living in some of the one-person homes told inspectors they were glad to escape bullying and enjoyed more attention from staff but they also often missed the company of other children and felt lonely.
Inspection reports revealed the homes did worse than larger children's homes in key areas, including support for individual children and the training and competency of staff.

Some councils do not use one person homes on principle and those who do tend not to do so as a first choice. Youngsters being placed usually have complex emotional or behavioural difficulties, learning disabilities and mental health problems, and may be difficult to control.
Some homes were found to be illegally limiting children's freedom - although they are not officially secure accommodation.

CSCI has also published a report on childrens services , The report found a need to improve progress in a number of areas including;

Increasing financial pressures are resulting in high eligibility criteria and thresholds for access to local council services. Children and families are, as a result, not always getting the help they need.
There is not enough support for children when they are taken into care and placed in a children’s home or with foster parents.
There are shortfalls in services to vulnerable children and young people with mental health problems, and in particular for children in care and their families.
Children in care do less well in education. While there have been improvements, more needs to be done, and done quickly.
Services to children with disabilities vary considerably depending on where they live. Services to children whose parents are disabled are similarly variable from one local council area to another.
There is insufficient coordination between children’s and adults’ social services teams in local councils to ensure coordinated help.